Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Regulation, Legal Certainty and Water

The rules of the game. Who does what in water, why it matters for investors and operators, and what has to change next.

I am an engineer, not a lawyer, regulation was something that arrived on my desk already digested.

A discharge limit in a specification, a permit that “someone” was handling...

When I started building The Water MBA almost four years ago and sketched the core pillars of our business, some columns kept appearing: policy, law, regulation...

And I’ll be honest, catching up on how laws and regulation actually play out in our business has been harder than I expected. And far more important.

Two “aha” moments changed how I see it.

  1. The first was reading Paul O’Callaghan’s book, The Dynamics of Water Innovation. I saw how technologies scaled up through the innovation process, often after just a touch of regulation. A new standard, a new limit, and suddenly a technology that sat for years in pilots becomes the default.

  2. The second is happening right now in Europe. The recast Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive is not just a stricter rulebook. It unlocks new requirements that, at the same time, switch on digitalisation, monitoring, energy neutrality, quaternary treatment and new financing models.

Regulation is not only the brake. It is often the ignition key.

I’m still far from where I want to be. But I’ve progressed a lot. So I wanted the best reference I know on this topic.

I heard Eduardo speak at an event in 2024, and he has a rare skill: he takes something as dense as water law and makes it clear, even entertaining. On a topic like this, that is gold.

Don’t miss the opportunity to listen to Eduardo.

Today’s publication is sponsored by the Innovation Driven Water Sustainability Conference (IDWS)

IDWS 2026 is the platform where global water leaders gather to deliver innovative solutions for water security. It takes place from 14 to 16 December 2026 at The Ritz-Carlton Hotel, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, bringing together attendees, leading exhibiting brands, top speakers, investors and innovative startups to accelerate progress across the water sector.

Building on the success of its previous editions, IDWS 2026 reinforces Saudi Arabia’s position as a global hub for water innovation and investment. From high-level government consultations to active project collaboration, it fosters partnerships, drives capital deployment and enables large-scale implementation.

Register at idwsc.com

I’m happy that IDWS has recognised our business school and community as a strategic partner, and that we’ll also be featured as partners at the event.

The key message

If you remember one thing from this episode, make it this headline. Everything else breaks down from it:

“Highlighting the importance of regulation and legal certainty for an effective administration, and for building a services market that attracts operators and investment”

Two outcomes, one condition. An administration that works, and a market that attracts capital and operators.

Both depend on clear rules that everyone can trust.

Who is Eduardo Orteu

Eduardo is a lawyer in the Public and Regulatory department at Gómez-Acebo & Pombo, specialised in environmental law, mainly waste and water. He has been at the firm for seven years.

Before that, he spent 20 years in Spain’s General State Administration as a member of the senior corps of civil administrators, now on leave.

Most of that time was at the Ministry of Environment: the Technical General Secretariat, regulatory processes, Spain’s Permanent Representation to the United Nations in New York (including the SDG agenda negotiations), and six years at the Directorate General for Water.

In his words, it gives him a 360-degree view: first as the regulator, now helping those who must comply with regulation.

Regulation is one piece of governance

Eduardo starts higher than I expected. Before talking about laws, he talks about governance.

From his years at the UN and around the 2030 Agenda, the conclusion is consistent: for many countries, the main water challenge is still the weakness of their governance systems.

Regulation is a critical part of that system, which rests on three pillars:

  • Institutions that manage water.

  • A regulatory framework under which those institutions operate.

  • Procedures with guarantees for applying the rules, run by whoever holds the competence.

All of it is woven through with public participation, essential in water because water policy cuts across every other sector.

That is the logic of integrated water resources management.

In a democratic country, there is one more layer: regulation is the backbone of the rule of law. Water is governed by law, like any other public policy.

From the top down: the Spanish legal pyramid

Eduardo’s clarity shines as usual every time I listen to him in any event or webinar.

Rules of the game, he says, answer two questions: first who does what, then how.

The Constitution sits at the top. It defines who does what, and it frames water as part of the public domain. This matters historically.

During the 19th century, Spain had two systems living side by side: public surface water managed by the administration, and private groundwater belonging to whoever owned the land where it was found.

Under the post-constitutional framework, starting with the 1985 Water Act, all water became public domain, managed by the public water administration.

I didn’t know that piece of history. It explains a lot.

EU law comes immediately after, with primacy over national law. The cornerstone is the Water Framework Directive and its “daughter” directives.

The Water Act (today a consolidated text gathering successive laws since 1985) builds the system around three ideas: integrated management, management by river basin, and the recognition, by law or by concession, of private rights to use water.

Regulations develop it: the Public Hydraulic Domain Regulation (use, control, protection and discharge permits) and the Hydrological Planning Regulation.

And here is a detail many engineers miss: hydrological plans in Spain are binding regulations, approved by Royal Decree.

The same goes for flood risk management plans. They are not strategy documents. They are law.

Two tensions run through the whole pyramid:

  • Spanish water law was built to allocate a scarce resource. Everything pivots around water rights: how they are recognised, administered and managed.

  • European water law is built to protect the environment. Because EU law prevails, environmental objectives have become a limiting factor for water use in Spain.

Who does what

The Constitution also splits competences in a politically decentralised State:

  • The State manages basins that cross more than one autonomous community. That is roughly 80–90% of the territory in water terms.

  • Autonomous communities can manage internal basins: the Balearic and Canary Islands, and parts of Andalusia, Catalonia and Galicia.

  • Unlike environment, where the State sets basic legislation and regions can go further, the State keeps full legislative competence over water. One Water Act for the whole country.

  • The State also holds the competence for works of general interest, which is what enabled Spain’s large water infrastructure build-out.

As Eduardo reminded me: without infrastructure, there is no access to water, no allocation and no treatment.

Then add the layers that complete the system: water quality standards, flood and drought management, and the rules for so-called non-conventional resources.

As he puts it, they are as conventional as any: Spain has been working on desalination since the 1960s and has had reuse regulation since 2007.

A Spanish invention the world adopted

Basin management and hydrological planning are, in Eduardo’s words, Spanish inventions that the EU later made its own.

Of course, every country is sovereign and sets its own rules. I can’t take Spain’s model and paste it into Chile.

But the UN and OECD recommendations both put basin planning and integrated resource management at the heart of good water governance.

From his time as focal point for SDG 6, secretary of the Conference of Ibero-American Water Directors and of the 5+5 Water Strategy for the Western Mediterranean, Eduardo sees the pattern clearly:

  • Latin America: almost every country manages by basin, except Chile, whose geography may justify it. Mexico, Brazil and Argentina built their models with Spanish technical cooperation (CEDEX, AECID).

  • North Africa: Morocco follows the same system as Spain. Tunisia doesn’t, because its rivers run parallel to the coast, so it links them with transfers. Algeria barely has rivers.

  • Turkey has also adopted basin management.

  • The striking exception is the United States. Think of the Colorado River.

Good rules are only half the job, though. As Eduardo says gently, if you have good rules, you have to comply with them.

Planning outlives politics

I asked the obvious question: is water regulation politicised?

Eduardo’s answer is nuanced. Water in Spain has always found confrontation, between territories and between parties, rather than unity.

But hydrological planning works better than the headlines suggest:

  • Plans run on six-year cycles that often outlast electoral cycles. A government frequently inherits a plan prepared by its predecessor.

  • The Committee of Competent Authorities brings the State, regions and local administrations together, and as a coordination forum it works.

  • Plans are largely driven by the technical teams of the river basin authorities, top-tier experts with long experience.

Spain is now entering its fourth planning cycle.

Where the real conflict sits is the National Hydrological Plan Act, which regulates transfers between basins (above 5 hm³ they require a law) and programmes State-funded works of general interest. Tajo-Segura, the failed Ebro transfer: that is where governments of every colour have promised in opposition what they could not deliver in office.

Two more points stayed with me:

  • Brussels as watchdog helps. Having the EU oversee compliance has been good for the system.

  • Spain’s water policy has always leaned towards supply rather than demand. With an agri-food industry that is the country’s largest, water is strategic. A State pact on water has been discussed for years. It has never happened.

The regulatory limits, most of them set in Brussels, are not optional. Since they can’t be skipped, the sensible path is agreement.

In the meantime, the planning cycles keep coming, government after government, and they mark the road.

The urban water cycle: where the system fails

Under the Spanish Constitution and the local government law, drinking water supply, sanitation and wastewater treatment are mandatory public services of municipalities.

The reason is historical.

A medieval city had walls, a market, water, lighting and little else.

Lighting has since left the municipal sphere. Water never did.

The problem: these services are extraordinarily “complex and expensive”, and they need economies of scale that most municipalities simply don’t have.

And each municipality sets its own tariff.

The result, as the sector knows well:

  • Tariffs have never covered the cost of service.

  • Spain now carries a deficit from ageing infrastructure and lack of renewal.

  • Standards keep rising.

Spain still hasn’t fully complied with the old Directive 91/271. That led to rulings from the Court of Justice of the EU: first declaratory, then with financial penalties.

Eduardo points out that the EU doesn’t want to fine. It spends years helping states comply. In Spain’s case, that didn’t work.

Now comes the recast directive. His analogy is perfect:

If you needed a 5 to pass the sanitation exam under the old directive, now you need an 8, and some would say a 9. And you hadn’t even reached the 5.

He adds a typical pressure in any river basin plan is poor wastewater treatment. The measure is identified, but the plant isn’t built.

Or it is built by the State, handed over to the municipality, and never switched on, because nobody wants to pass the cost on to the tariff.

His view is that this calls for a reform of the Water Act to better integrate the urban cycle into the whole water cycle, innovative regulatory formulas to help, and oblige, municipalities to deliver.

Extended producer responsibility for quaternary treatment of micropollutants is the most talked-about innovation of the new directive. It is not the most important one. The whole system needs rethinking.

This is exactly my second “aha” moment, seen from the other side. The directive unlocks new requirements and new markets.

Desalination: the pieces are there, but they don’t fit

I asked whether desalination has a specific legal problem in Spain. The answer explains a lot of what I see in bids abroad versus at home.

  • Desalination as a production activity has very limited, insufficient regulation. Once the water enters the system, it follows the same regime as any other: a concession to use it.

  • 99.9% of Spain’s water infrastructure has been public initiative, mainly the State. Investments were recovered (only partially) through charges such as the regulation levy and water use tariff.

  • There is no specific PPP legislation for the water sector. Works and service concessions exist, but in practice PPPs have not worked.

Then comes the twist. Desalination was driven by the State through Acuamed, which built plants and distributed water without concessions.

The mess reached the Supreme Court.

Its recent doctrine treats desalinated water as public domain and requires a concession not only for the user, but also for the project itself: building the plant.

Eduardo’s verdict: it makes no sense.

And the timing is ironic, because the Government has just reformed the reuse framework so that treating, regenerating and supplying reclaimed water to a third party is not a public service.

It needs an authorisation, not a public contract, and the end user still needs a reuse concession.

Apply that same logic to desalination, and private initiative could finally move.

There is demand. The administrations don’t have the money. The plants are identified in the programmes of measures.

Yet it seems we need another major drought to act...

This is the key message in its purest form: without legal certainty, there is no market, no operators and no investment.

Water rights: the cornerstone

Eduardo calls water rights the cornerstone of the Spanish system: the right to private use of water, recognised by the administration, mainly through a concession.

How it works:

  • A concession must be compatible with the hydrological plan. If the water is already committed, you won’t get it.

  • There is a priority order: urban supply first, then irrigation, then industrial uses (with renewable energy production now ahead of other industry), then recreational. Each plan can adjust the order, but supply always comes first.

  • When applicants share the same use category, the law runs a competition of projects: the application is published, others can apply, and the administration chooses the one that best serves the general interest.

  • Concessions are recorded in the Water Register, which protects them against third parties.

The reality today: water is already counted.

Most available resources in the plans are committed.

New rights only appear when concessions expire (supply and irrigation renew automatically; other uses don’t), or from new sources like reuse and desalination.

And one sentence every engineer and investor should keep in mind: having a right to use water does not guarantee access to water.

That depends on whether there is water. That is why reservoirs matter so much.

Environmental objectives come first here too. Ecological flows are treated as a restriction: the basin authority sets them aside, and only what’s left, if not already committed, can be allocated.

Some of these rights go back centuries. The Water Tribunal of Valencia, where irrigators in traditional dress gather in front of the cathedral, settles disputes over the royal irrigation channels of the Turia, privileges dating back to the Middle Ages and the irrigation systems of al-Andalus.

It is recognised by UNESCO as intangible cultural heritage and is likely the oldest functioning dispute-resolution institution in Europe. Murcia has its Council of Good Men.

Water Tribunal of the plain of Valencia - Wikipedia

Today those irrigators hold registered concessions as irrigation communities. Once the basin authority delivers the water, management “in low” is delegated to them. Participation, again, built into the system.

Water stewardship: the regulatory risk nobody talks about

Eduardo recently wrote about the regulatory risks of water stewardship, a topic very present in our community. (He also struggles to translate stewardship into Spanish. So do I.)

His two warnings:

  1. Check whether what you do is still voluntary. For large companies under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, reporting impacts on natural resources is mandatory. If it’s mandatory, you must do it the way the rules say, not with the freedom you had before.

  2. Beware of generic environmental claims. EU consumer protection and anti-greenwashing rules ban generic claims such as “eco-friendly” or “very sustainable”. What is a “water positive” company? Nobody knows, because it isn’t regulated.

His advice: if you claim something, be able to prove it.

Go with a good hydrologist. Go to the basin authority.

Check your actions against the programmes of measures in the hydrological plans. Some “savings” aren’t savings in the light of planning. Many actions do have real positive impact. The challenge is how you communicate it and who certifies it.

And a principle that applies far beyond stewardship: when regulation is unclear, regulatory risk is higher.

A personal question to close

I ended with a personal one.

A friend in the State administration, a “Ingeniero de Caminos del Estado”, has been insisting for months that I should sit the civil service exams.

He even sent me the syllabus, whose first module opens with the basic laws.

I studied Civil Engineering partly because I wanted to work in public-service infrastructure. I graduated into the crisis and took another path.

Eduardo didn’t hesitate. Every State civil engineer he has worked with who ended up in water told him the same: they never planned to end up there, and they would never leave.

It’s a good moment to join, there’s less competition and engineers are needed. And public service offers a special kind of pay: not the economic one, but serving others and your country.

Lately, the state of infrastructure in my country has become impossible to ignore.

Two high-speed rail accidents, with more than 100 casualties between them.

Dams, where I worry about the condition of drainage and overflow mechanisms, and where the safety risk grows day by day, especially in a wet season like this one, with reservoirs running high.

And roads: a colleague I know well had a tyre burst because of the poor state of the road surface, and nearly crashed.

So my heart says: join the administration, build a career there, and work for society to make things better. There is no better purpose.

But my mind says: financially, it’s not the best option right now compared with the private sector. And there is a political ceiling, where the top decision-makers are appointed for their politics, not their capabilities.

So here I am, with the syllabus papers on my desk, gathering dust for the last five months.

Back to the headline

From the Constitution down to a concession title, from Brussels down to a municipal tariff, everything in this conversation comes back to one sentence:

Regulation and legal certainty are what make an administration effective, and what turn water services into a market that attracts operators and investment.

When the rules are clear, plans get executed, plants get switched on and capital shows up.

When they aren’t, we identify the measures, write them into law, and wait for the next drought.

Thank you, Eduardo, for making something this complex feel this clear. You are really awesome!

Key quotes

On governance

“For many countries, the main challenge in water is still the weakness of water governance systems.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 03:21

On the rule of law

“Laws, in the end, tell us who does what, under which procedure and for what purpose.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 15:01

On basin management

“Basin management is a Spanish invention that the European Union later made its own.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 07:49

On planning and politics

“At least the hydrological plans give you a technical roadmap, grounded in knowledge, that tries to overcome territorial conflicts.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 25:12

“Having Brussels and the European Union as a watchdog for compliance helps us.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 25:12

On the urban water cycle

“Tariffs for mandatory public services have never covered the cost of the service.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 32:13

“If you needed a 5 to pass the sanitation exam, now you need an 8, and some would say a 9.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 32:13

“The State built it and handed it to the municipality, but the municipality didn’t switch it on because it didn’t want to pass on the tariffs.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 35:32

On desalination and private investment

“With current regulation, the private sector is not encouraged to develop public-private partnerships.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 38:41

“Private initiative has room here to cover a space the administration can’t reach.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 40:54

On water rights

“Having the right to private use of water does not guarantee access to the resource, because that depends on whether there is water or not.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 47:43

“It is very difficult today to obtain a new concession, because the water is already counted.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 45:30

On water stewardship

“This yoghurt will make you slim? Then don’t eat the yoghurt.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 52:46

“When regulation is not clear, regulatory risk is higher.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 57:16

On public service

“They had never thought they would end up in the water sector, but they will never leave it.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 58:59

“Working as a civil servant brings a special kind of pay. Not the economic one, but serving others and serving your country.”

— Eduardo Orteu, min 59:41

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?